Racedeck black and white checkerboard floor covering

I Will Never Epoxy My Garage Floor (What I Will Do Instead)

Racedeck Garage Floor TileRacedeck

I would need to hire a professional if I wanted to epoxy my garage floor. I’m choosing the plastic tile because, by myself, I can install a PVC tile that is durable and beautiful.

You need to do a lot of cleaning and fixing for a cement floor to accept paint or epoxy Even then, the epoxy requires expert application to stick.

I want to cover my garage floor, but I don’t want all of that work.

What are my garage floor alternatives to paint and epoxy?

  • Garage Floor Mats
    • a garage floor containment mat
    • a garage floor parking mat
  • Plastic or Vinyl Interlocking Tiles
    • plastic interlocking tiles made of polypropylene
    • plastic interlocking tiles made from PVC (polyvinyl chloride)
    • plastic interlocking tiles made from vinyl composite tile (VCT) (NOT RECOMMENDED, see article)

After researching this article, I’m leaning toward installing PVC interlocking tiles. They look amazing. Floor preparation involves a reasonable amount of cleanup. They don’t have noise issues, and they’re durable. But I’m still looking at the other options. Floor mats are usually made of vinyl or a woven, carpet-like fabric. They cover only part of the garage floor. Mats need almost no preparation work. Mats need cleaning after use. Containment mats protect the cement floor from snow and ice, but they’re not super strong. Polypropylene interlocking tiles look amazing but are very loud to walk on. VCTs (vinyl composition tiles) are not recommended for garages. Manufacturers will not honor VCT garage floor installations.  Vinyl tiles look great. They require a ton of work to install. They require a ton more work to maintain. And they’re not warrantied when installed in garages.

Garage Floor Mats

Garage floor mats don’t cover the entire garage floor and they’re not there for looks. They hold onto the snow and rain on your car so that it doesn’t fall onto the cement floor.

Garage floor matsGarage Floor Mats cover only part of the garage floor. They make sense if you’re only concerned about the area under the cars.

Garage Floor Containment Mats

The AutoFloorGuard containment mat captures snow

If you live in a snowy or rainy area, you might enjoy a garage floor containment mat. You can put a containment mat on the original floor, or on top of a new tile floor.

A containment mat is like a kiddie pool for the snow and rain falling off of your car. They have raised sides to hold in the liquid and slush.

When you drive into the garage, your front and back tires will drive over the front lip. It’s like a pool noodle speed bump.

They don’t cover the entire garage floor and they’re not there for looks. They hold onto the snow and rain on your car so that it doesn’t fall onto the cement floor.

Garage Floor Containment Mat Warranties

Warranties aren’t spectacular at around 1 year limited. In general, PVC fabric is resistant to moisture, sun fade and garage chemicals.

Garage Floor Containment Mat Construction

Use a containment mat for water management, not for strength and durability. They’re not strong like plastic tiles. In fact, some won’t hold up to studded snow tires.

Containment mats are usually made of nonporous vinyl

Garage Floor Containment Mat Noise

Containment mats have no noise factor beyond the sound of a little bit of fabric rustling on a very quiet day.

Garage Floor Containment Mat Tool Requirements

You do not need any tools to lay out a containment mat.

Garage Floor Containment Mat Materials

Containment mats are usually made of PVC fabric. The quieter plastic garage floor tiles are also made of PVC.

Garage Floor Containment Mat Installation

Put the containment mat on the floor where you park the car, inside the garage.

Garage Floor Containment Glue/Adhesive/Tape

Some owners might find that their mats move a little. One good solution is double-sided carpet tape around the outside edges. If the floor is very dirty, the tape might not stick.

Containment mats have raised sides

Containment mats have raised sides

Garage Floor Containment Mat Weight Capacity

Containment mats are car mats. They will hold at least a snow-covered SUV worth of weight.

Garage Floor Containment Mat Subfloor Preparation

Clean the floor before laying out the mat. You can get away with not cleaning the floor first, if it’s not too dirty.

Garage Floor Containment Mat Anti-Fatigue Properties

Containment mats have no cushioning or springs. They don’t have anti-fatigue properties.

Garage Floor Containment Mat Cleanup

Push the snow over the front mat lip. The broom and snow will push the mat out of the way. The mat edge recovers right away.

You can also use a wet/dry vac to clean up the water and snow. If the slush is not too heavy, you can also pick up the mat and unload it outside.

Garage Floor Containment Mat Cost

Containment mats cost between $130 and $140, which works out to around $1.15 to $1.40 per square foot.

Garage Floor Parking Mats

The Armorall floor mat comes in many sizes

The Armorall floor mat comes in many sizes

Garage floor parking matsGarage floor parking mats are made of carpet or plastic. They sit under the car, like containment mats. Parking mats don’t have the lipped edges to contain the falling slush and rain.

Parking mats also protect the floor from tire rubber stains. They’re useful for absorbing or holding slush and rain. Containment mats will hold more water than parking mats.

Some garage floor mats are “containment mats” without the name “containment.”

Auto Care Products makes a nice “garage floor mat” with a small lip edge.

The edge contains mud, slush and rain.

They claim their mat holds “gallons of liquid.”

That’s a “garage floor containment mat.”

Garage Floor Parking Mat Warranties

Floor mat warranties run from about 60 days to three years long.

Garage Floor Parking Mat Construction

Some garage floor mats are made of heavy duty vinyl. They have plastic sides. Some are polyester carpets. The carpets absorb rather than contain liquids.

Look for a PVC waterproof backing. PVC will waterproof the bottom of the mat.

Garage Floor Parking Mat Noise

Vinyl mats have a slight fabric noise and carpet mats are pretty quiet.

Garage Floor Parking Mat Tool Requirements

You do not need tools to use a garage floor mat. You might sweep or vacuum the floor before using the mat.

The Drymat floor mat rolls out onto the garage floor

Garage Floor Parking Mat Materials

You do not need any extra materials to make garage floor mats work well.

Garage Floor Parking Mat Installation

Place the mat under where you park the cars in the garage.

Garage Floor Parking Mat Garage Floor Containment Glue/Adhesive/Tape

In general, you do not need to glue a garage floor parking mat. Some people find a little bit of double-side tape around the mat perimeter keeps the mat in place.

Floor mats protect the cement floor underneath

Garage Floor Parking Mat Weight Capacity

Most mats handle any vehicle’s weight. Some mats cannot stand up to a very hot tire making a quick turn. The rubber comes off onto the mat.

Garage Floor Parking Mat Floor Preparation

You should sweep and clean the floor before using double-sided tape. If you are not using tape, you can put the mat onto a dusty floor.

Garage Floor Parking Mat Anti-Fatigue Properties

Some mats give a little bounce and give.

Carpet-like garage floor mats can be pressure washed

Garage Floor Parking Mat Cleanup

You can push-broom or wet-vac a wet parking mat. Carpet mats will contain a lot of wet crud. Hit them with a soapy pressure washer bath, then rinse.

Garage Floor Parking Mat Cost

Floor mats run from between $75 and $200, which averages out to about $1.04 to $1.34 per square foot.

These Incstore PVC tiles use a puzzle pattern to interlock

These Incstore PVC tiles use a puzzle pattern to interlock

Plastic Garage Floor Interlocking Tiles

Polypropylene tiles are very hard. They are partially hollow underneath. Thus, these tiles can make a lot of noise when you walk on them.

Plastic garage floor interlocking tiles can be spectacular looking. Plastic tiles have long warranties and good chemical, water and stain resistance. Two of the most popular plastic tile materials are polypropylene and PVC.

Polypropylene Garage Floor Interlocking Tiles

Polypropylene garage floor tilesPolypropylene garage floor tiles are one of the most popular garage floor covering options.

Polypropylene is a very hard, durable plastic.

Polypropylene Tile Warranties

Tiles made from polypropylene have 10 to 20 year warranties. The tiles are not unbreakable, but they’re very strong.

A Speedway Diamond polypropylene floor tile

A Speedway Diamond polypropylene floor tile

Polypropylene Tile Construction

Only part of the bottom part of the tile reaches the floor. The rest is hollow. It’s a slight misnomer, but this is why they’re called “floating” floors. Only the ribs touch the garage floor.

Polypropylene Tile Noise

All polypropylene tiles are very hard. They are partially hollow underneath. Thus, these tiles can make a lot of noise when you walk on them.

If you’re the kind of person who likes a really thick, quiet carpet, you won’t like poly tile noise.

Polypropylene Tile Tool Requirements

Most manufacturers say that their tiles require no tools to install. That’s mostly true, in that there are no trowels, brooms and brushes as you’d need with an epoxy floor.

installing the Blocktile garage floor polypropylene tiles

Installing the Blocktile garage floor polypropylene tiles

In practice, you need a cutting tool and a mallet to install poly tile.

You can use a utility knife, a tile cutter (with water), a power saw or a table saw.

Most people use a rubber mallet to flatten the tile joints.

You can also just step on all of the cracks to flatten the tiles.

Polypropylene Tile Materials

A rubber underlayment will help soften some of the plastic tile’s noise.

Polypropylene Tile Installation

Polypropylene tiles are handsome but noisy

Polypropylene tiles are handsome but noisy

Please follow manufacturer’s instructions. This article is not about any specific garage floor tile installation method.

Polypropylene garage tiles usually snap together using a hook and loop scheme. Usually the female loops stick out from two sides, and the male pegs stick out from the bottom of two sides. The pegs insert into the loops.

You can hit them with a rubber mallet, or step on them, to make them lie flat.

Start the poly tile installation at the front of the garage.

Place the male (flat side with pegs underneath) side facing out of the garage door. Angle it so that the other male side is facing to your left. The two female sides would then land facing the back and right side of the garage.

Most polypropylene models include ramps. These are slightly angled plastic pieces. Place the ramps at the front of the garage. Ramps smooth out riding into the garage.

GarageTrac polypropylene tiles in black and red

GarageTrac polypropylene tiles in black and red

Polypropylene Tile Glue/Adhesive/Tape

You do not need adhesive, glue or tape when installing polypropylene garage tiles.

Polypropylene Tile Resistance to Elements

Polypropylene tiles tend to be resistant to stains, moisture and garage chemicals. Most resist fading in the sun.

Polypropylene tiles withstand extreme temperatures. PVC, rubber and wood expand more than polypropylene.

Polypropylene Tile Weight Capacity

Polypropylene tiles can hold a ridiculous amount of weight. I’ve seen ratings such as 3,000 lb. per tile, and 80,000 lb. per installation.

That’s if the weight is spread out. If the weight is concentrated in one spot, poly tiles will yield.

Motorcycle kickstands and car jacks can leave lasting impressions in the plastic ribs.

Manufacturers usually recommend putting plywood under kickstands and floor jacks.

Polypropylene Tile Garage Floor Preparation

Clean the garage floor to your liking. A poly floor will install well so long as the floor is relatively free of debris. It would bother me to install over a dirty floor. But technically, it’s not a problem for these tiles.

Polypropylene Tile Anti-Fatigue Properties

Being very hard, polypropylene tiles have no anti-fatigue properties. They don’t smush in a bit when you stand on them, so they don’t lessen the pressure on your joints.

Polypropylene Tile Cleanup

Vacuum and mop poly garage tiles. You can use a mild detergent. Some manufacturers suggest using Purple PowerPurple Power.

Polypropylene Tile Costs

Polypropylene garage tiles cost about $2 to $3 per square foot.

PVC Interlocking Garage Floor Tiles

PVC garage tilesGarage Floor Tiles are slightly softer than polypropylene. They are more flexible.

PVC Tile Warranties

PVC warranties are on the long side at 10 to 25 years long.

PVC Tile Construction

PVC tiles sit directly on the garage floor.

PVC garage tiles are thinner than polypropylene tiles. PVC tiles are solid. Poly tiles are hollow. The entire bottom of the PVC tile sits on the garage floor.

PVC Tile Noise

PVC is also much quieter than polypropylene tiles. This is the biggest difference between PVC and polypropylene tiles. PVC is quiet when you walk on it. It’s not a padded carpet — it’s still plastic. But it’s a reasonable plastic noise, not an echo chamber.

PVC Tile Tool Requirements

Most manufacturers claim that you don’t need tools to install PVC tile.

In practice, you’ll want a rubber mallet and a utility knife.

PVC is the softer plastic. You can cut it with a sharp knife.

Use the rubber mallet to encourage the pieces to lie flat. Or walk on the joints to flatten them.

PVC Tile Materials

If your garage floor has moisture issues, apply a concrete sealer.

Use a sealer on “weepy” garage floors.

Consider using a sealer if the floor is flat.

You want the floor under PVC tiles to drain.

These Incstore PVC tiles use a puzzle pattern to interlock

These Incstore PVC tiles use a puzzle pattern to interlock

PVC Tile Installation

Please follow manufacturer’s instructions.

This article is not about any specific garage floor tile installation method.

Start PVC tile installation a couple of feet from a wall.

Install the edges at the end of the installation process.

PVC expands and contracts.

Leave a gap between the tile edge and the walls.

PVC Tile Glue/Adhesive/Tape

If your PVC tile installation moves, apply some pressure-sensitive tape to the perimeter. Not all installations have movement. Only those that do would require some extra help.

PVC Tile Resistance to the Elements

PVC garage tiles are not as good as polypropylene tiles at repelling dirt, chemicals and tire stains.

A hot tire spinning out on a PVC tile might melt all over that tire. That’s an extreme situation and not likely to happen. But there’s more chance of it happening with PVC than with polypropylene garage tiles.

Street tar stains will probably come up with a cleaner-degreaser such as Purple Power.

The tire might melt onto the tile.

You’ll find it easier to replace these tiles than to lean them.

PVC Tile Weight Capacity

PVC has enormous load capacity. I’ve seen weight ratings of 80,000 lbs.

If you drop something heavy on PVC, the tile might respond with a dimple that eventually heals. The material will give way and bounce back as it has some built-in flexibility.

PVC Tile Garage Floor Preparation

It’s OK to install PVC on floors with a slight grade or small cracks.

But be aware that the entire bottom of the PVC tile sits on the garage floor.

Cleaning the floor is important.

Crud won’t escape the tile’s flat bottom.

Allow the garage floor to dry before installing the PVC tile.

You can install PVC tiles on less than perfect garage floors.

PVC Tile Anti-Fatigue Properties

If really hard surfaces bother your joints, PVC is a better choice than polypropylene.

PVC is not an anti-fatigue material.

PVC are more flexible than polypropylene tiles.

PVC is more forgiving and bouncy.

PVC Tile Cleanup

Cleaning PVC tile is easy.

You can sweep or vacuum the dirt from the tiles.

Then wash the tiles with a mop and soapy water.

PVC responds well to warm water and mild detergents.

Treat scuffs with a high gloss vinyl floor polish like Armstrong ShinekeeperArmstrong Shinekeeper.

PVC Tile Costs

PVC interlocking tile costs between $4.50 and $7.50 per square foot.

VCT Interlocking Garage Floor Tiles

An Armstrong VCT (vinyl composition tile)

An Armstrong VCT (vinyl composition tile)

I can’t find any manufacturers who will warranty VCT for garage installations. Not Johnson, not Tarkett, not Armstrong. If you install VCT in your garage, don’t expect the manufacturer to honor the tile warranty.

VCT garage floor tilesVCT floor tiles are cheap. In exchange for this low price, you have a lot more work.

Before installing VCT (Vinyl Composition Tile), clean the garage floor. Repair any cracks. Don’t install VCT on cracks or floors that are not flat.

After installation, wax and buff the floor. Repeat every 6 months to 1 year.

And don’t spill gasoline on VCT.

VCT Warranties

Dealers will sell you VCT.

It’s up to you to check on the garage installation warranty.

VCT Construction

VCT are solid, thin and flexible. They don’t move around because you glue them to the garage floor.

VCT

VCT is very quiet. It has a rubbery give to it. Some vinyl tiles can be a little squeaky.

VCT Tool Requirements

You might need to smooth garage floor rough areas with a concrete grinderConcrete Grinder.

Use a trowel to apply cement repair mixCement Repair or concrete toppingConcrete Topping.

Flatten the tile with a vinyl rollerVinyl Roller.

VCT Materials

You’ll need adhesive for non-self-stick VCT.

VCT Installation

VCT installation starts at the garage door and works backwards. Spread glue within a reachable area, wait for it to dry, and then lay the tile on the glue. Roll the vinyl with a vinyl roller.

VCT Glue/Adhesive/Tape

The manufacturer will recommend the appropriate VCT glue.

VCT Resistance to the Elements

Unwaxed VCT is not resistant to much. Once waxed and buffed, VCT is resistant to chemicals and water. However gasoline and solvents will ruin the VCT fabric right through the wax.

VCT is resistant to salt.

VCT Weight Capacity

Probably owing to the fact that manufacturers don’t warranty VCT in garages, I was unable to find VCT load capacities. Plenty of people have used VCT in their garage and parked cars on it. Just imagine parking a car on a vinyl kitchen floor. It’s like that.

VCT Subfloor Preparation

VCT will fail if the floor is not perfectly clean and free of oil. Use crack filling compound on cracks, cement repair mix or crack filler on contraction joints, and concrete topping on pitting. Grind down rough spots with a cement grinder.

VCT Anti-Fatigue Properties

VCT is somewhat softer than plastic tiles but less soft than rubber.

VCT Cleanup

VCT is cleaned with broom and then a mop and soapy water. VCT has to be re-waxed and buffed.

VCT Cost

VCT interlocking floor tiles cost between $0.66 and $1.05 per square foot.

Which Floor Covering for My Garage?

I want a garage floor covering that looks good, doesn’t require a ton of preparation, and doesn’t require more than a mop and vacuum to clean.

I definitely would not use polypropylene tiles because I don’t like the noise they make. VCT are completely out as they require way too much preparation and upkeep.

At this point in the research, I see myself getting a PVC interlocking tile floor with two containment mats on top.

The PVC tile is the strongest option that doesn’t make a racket when you walk on it.

In the winter, we usually wipe off the snow off of the cars before pulling into the garage.

PVC tiles are moisture resistant, not waterproof.

A containment mat on top of the PVC tile will keep the snow from melting all over the floor, and save us the hassle of wiping the cars while it’s snowing.

I’ll be digging into PVC tile brands, and adding to this article if I find more floor covering solutions.